Guests - Jonathan Dever, Dave Smith

The Vendor Owns the Network, and Washington Pays Rent

Jonathan Dever has been a banker, a consumer attorney, and a Republican state representative from Ohio who chaired the House Financial Institutions, Housing and Urban Development Committee. He came to talk about how systems fail — and the nationwide air travel breakdown was his Exhibit A.

Start with the wiring. Much of the system still runs on the old copper lines — the electrified descendants of the telegraph — in a decades-long migration to fiber optics that never finished. In the 1990s, as Newt Gingrich argued in a Wall Street Journal piece Dever cited, Washington decided private contractors could move faster than government. What it actually did, Dever says, was hand over the keys.

Secretary Sean Duffy said it plainly on Meet the Press: "I can't cancel the network that they own that I operate on."

"That's very, very scary," Dever said. "We didn't contract someone to do something for us. They actually hold the system now, contractually, because we gave it over. Congress ceded that."

His analogy: buy a hundred-unit apartment building, then pay the tenants rent to live in your own building. And the vendor has form. This is the third time it has made the same mistake — in Dallas last December, a router switch interrupted fewer than a thousand flights and everyone chalked it up to weather. "And the sad part is, they just renewed these people's contract in July for another twenty years." This time it was not one facility: 17 of 22 air traffic control centers were hit.

FAA Administrator Bedford says investigators are looking at three possibilities — a faulty installation, a bad configuration, or a bad router. The vendor insists its Juniper device didn't fail; the routers are now being inspected by the FAA and the FBI. Federal officials say it was not a cyberattack, and Marco Rubio is telling the public the same: a series of unfortunate blunders. Dever's own theory is simpler and dumber: a cutover to the new system, flipped during peak traffic, firing thousands of connection attempts a second until it choked on its own traffic. His fix is not rocket science: "Do it at 3 a.m., when no one's flying."

The Grift Formula

Why does a broken vendor keep its contract and then ask for more? Because that, Dever says, is the grift — and it has a formula. The government signs a contract that protects the vendor. The agency grows complacent and comfortable with the status quo. There is no accountability in statute or rule. "And then what happens is the ordinary citizens are the ones that are stuck at the gate and paying the price."

The rub, he says, is the ask on top of it: another $50 billion to build a new system — with no explanation of how we got into this position, no accounting of why that amount, and no safeguards described to keep it from happening again. Whether the law even allows the government to reclaim a system it contractually gave away is an open question nobody has answered.

To be fair, Dever knows Duffy from his House Banking Committee days and believes him thorough and diligent. "He inherited this. This is something that didn't happen overnight. This has been a problem that's really been around since World War II."

Basics, Not Emotion

The outage is a symptom; the disease is a Congress that stopped doing basics. Dever knocked thousands of doors in Arizona this spring and knew by May how the fall would go. Ask candidates why they were running and the only answer was emotion: "We can't let those crazy people in. That's not a reason." Republicans, he says, won in 2024 promising to fix inflation and improve people's lives — "and we did not deliver. We talked a big game, but we didn't do basic simple things."

The math is the basics. As of the last fiscal year, 19 cents of every dollar the Treasury collects goes to interest only. Since that fiscal year ended in September, the national debt has grown by another $600 billion. "If we continue the way we're going, by 2035, fifty cents on every dollar that we bring into the Treasury is going to be interest only."

His letter in PJ Media — a "Seven for '27" wish list — starts with energy: Texas makes plenty of diesel, which is also heating oil, but a stupid law written 106 years ago keeps it from reaching a Northeast facing a hard winter. "We can fix that very, very simply in a matter of a couple of days, if they really cared." Second is Social Security: without structural reform, retirees face a cut of up to 17 percent of all current benefits in 2032. He has written a white paper that fixes it structurally for every generation and sent it to a senator now partnering with Elizabeth Warren on the issue. His own senator is Bernie Moreno; Ohio's other seat, once held by Vice President Vance, just flipped to Sherrod Brown.

Dever's philosophy of governing fits in a traffic metaphor. Laws should be rules of the road — this way only, that way only — that keep people from head-on collisions while leaving them free to travel where they want, with as many kids and dogs in the car as they like. "What government should not do is try to micromanage how many gallons of gas you can keep in your car." You don't need all 435 members thinking that way, he says. "You just need five or six, and that can change the entire place." He is encouraged by Jim Jordan taking the helm for House Republicans, and even by the size of the incoming Democratic majority: a speaker who can afford to lose 20 or 30 votes can afford to govern — Reagan and Tip O'Neill took their potshots on TV, then had a scotch and got things done; Gingrich and Clinton did the same.

The Art of Extraction

Dever learned the pattern in the foreclosure crisis of 2008 to 2014, when Arizona and Ohio were the apex of the collapse — stated-income loans, incredible fraud, and an analog paper-based legal system colliding with a securitized, computerized world. Kathleen lived the Arizona side of it: she worked for the attorney general's office during those years, when the state sued Bank of America, which had bought Countrywide, and the other major banks over the paper and who owned it. "By the time the paper got sorted out," the pattern was the same one Dever describes — bad law, written for an analog world, that legislatures never updated while the systems changed around it. He represented banks until too-big-to-fail absorbed all his community banks; then he crossed the aisle of the courtroom and sued the big ones, JPMorgan among them. In the legislature, he fixed Ohio's law, and the U.S. Senate modeled bills on what he passed.

What he identified is what he calls the art of extraction — the extraction methodology. He calls its shape the Genesis 3 pattern: God made a perfect garden and gave one rule; Eve added to the rule — don't eat and don't touch — and the decay began. "We create well-intentioned things. We want to help people that are homeless, we want to help people that are sick, we want to help seniors. And you take this good thing and you just start adding layers on it, and that's where people come in and start figuring out how to extract and how to exploit people."

His forthcoming Grift trilogy dissects the pattern industry by industry — pharma, health care, banking, even organized religion. The first book arrives early next year. In the meantime he writes three times a week on his Substack, the Dever Dialogue, where the book's pre-order list lives. He turns 54 in about a week. Kathleen's benediction: find people who still want to solve problems instead of pointing fingers — and give the next generation something better. Her twentieth grandchild is about to be born in Richmond, Virginia.

Declaring War on Data Centers

Kathleen turned home. Arizona Democrats have set their sights on their first major policy goal: a moratorium on data center development, a campaign promise of Attorney General Kris Mayes, who says she will use every regulatory step available to halt more than a hundred data centers now in the development pipeline.

The problems, Kathleen argues, are legal and factual. A modern data center is self-sufficient — it does not take the community's water, it does everything itself — and the profitability for the community that hosts one can be high. And the attorney general cannot simply declare war on a legal business. Before the state's three-year break in data center tax exemptions could take effect, the Arizona Commerce Authority approved 107 applications for those breaks. Pima County's own Board of Supervisors imposed a data center moratorium in Marana that the Goldwater Institute called illegal. And Mayes plans to be aggressive with antitrust law — which, after yesterday's lesson from Robert Bork Jr., Kathleen calls a misapplication that will cost the state millions. Among her targets: SpaceX's proposed 747-acre supercomputing and artificial intelligence data center in Cochise County — the project that could save that county. Governor Katie Hobbs, meanwhile, wants data centers to pay their "fair share" for energy, with guardrails to keep them from raising energy costs or taking water.

John Kavanagh, the Senate's former majority leader and its incoming minority leader, says the whole effort is moot: the moratorium was so poorly worded that the hundred-plus data centers already in the pipeline can't be stopped. Kathleen's prediction: an epic fail for the governor and the attorney general — but watch the ESA program next, because the pattern is national.

Seven Counties Under Mud, and the Governor Is Hiking

Two weeks after a historic flood demolished homes across the Verde Valley, residents say Governor Hobbs has left them to dig out on their own. The November 1 flood — some call it a 500-year flood — hit seven of Arizona's fifteen counties. Some 700 homes were affected, some gone entirely, some filled with mud to the ceiling fans. The Verde River rose more than 20 feet through Camp Verde; Oak Creek rose 15 feet in a very short time. DPS spokesman Bart Graves called it an extreme emergency; crews made more than 60 rescues across Yavapai County. Volunteers clearing homes by hand have posted 132 addresses needing tractors, bobcats, trailers, and dump trucks. A Cottonwood business owner, Anthony Lozano, put his own work on hold to dig out homes for free. Lowe's offered a $40,000 discount toward a $100,000 supply order — and Camp Verde's town manager says the flood costs blew past the town budget almost immediately.

The state's total help so far: a $200,000 emergency fund. "Anybody who's had any damage to their home knows that will take care of maybe one home, if at all," Kathleen said. Hobbs posted on November 1 that she was closely monitoring the flooding; on November 2 she posted a picture of herself hiking the campaign trail. What she has not done is the one thing only a governor can do: request a federal disaster declaration from FEMA. Representative Eli Crane's office confirmed on November 6 that no request has been submitted; Crane toured Camp Verde on November 13 and pledged that the moment she files, he will press for swift approval. His Rural Disaster Fairness Act would cut FEMA's damage threshold by 50 percent for rural counties. Even SBA disaster loans stay locked until the state asks. "There is money and resources because this is an extreme situation, and we are not getting access to it because our governor is not doing her job."

Dave Smith, who grew up in northern Arizona, added the geography: ephemeral rivers that exist only when it rains, canyon after canyon funneling flash floods, houses built into Flagstaff's valleys, and burn scars like Mount Elden — once a wonderful watershed, now a bare water conduit aimed at east Flagstaff — left by forest mismanagement. The flooding itself, he says, is not uncommon. The absence is. And it baffles him politically: Flagstaff is bright blue, the reservations and the San Juan River country are her own coalition — "it doesn't cost her anything to declare the crisis and get the government in there. And it's costing Arizonans their safety, their lives, their possessions."

Smith and Winn: No Backup Systems

Smith and Winn ranged wider. Dave and Betsy flew home from visiting grandkids in Indianapolis and landed half an hour before the nationwide ground stop — miraculous timing that strangers didn't share: missed cruises, missed weddings, missed everything. The cascade keeps cascading: banking down on Saturday, and per Dave, NSA systems down for three days. His sermon was redundancy. "We had all these people telling us, if you get reliant on that, you're really going to have trouble if you don't have a backup system. Well, we apparently don't have any backup systems at all. Where is this redundancy?"

On the counselors-instead-of-cops plan out of New York — yesterday's topic with Jarred Weisfeld — Dave, a former law enforcement officer, was blunt: riots like these are planned and scheduled, not spontaneous, and a cadre of unarmed counselors will not stop one. And on the election just past, the frustration he and Kathleen share is about facts that never arrive: Pima County's recorder kept finding ballots after the election had allegedly been closed three separate times, reopening it again and again. "When I ask for facts, which are evidence, no one — then I'm just called a name. I'm just called a denier." An honest process, Dave argues, is the only alternative to political violence: "I have to know that I can change my present condition through political action and not political violence."

The Bright Spot: Wildcats and the Bowl

They ended on joy. Last night the Arizona Wildcats handed it to UConn — ranked second in the country — 85 to 79, jumping out 10–0 and dominating, with four Wildcats in double figures. Ivan Kharchenkov led with 20 points, seven assists, five rebounds, and two steals; the seven-foot-two Motiejus Krivas posted a double-double, 18 points and 12 boards. Braylon Mullins led all scorers with 29 for UConn — one guy against a team. The win came despite the NCAA: right before the game, it refused to clear forward RJ Godfrey, a Clemson transfer who averaged 12 points a game last year, even after a Pima County judge granted a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction on Tuesday. The university says it is not done fighting.

And Kathleen closed with the Arizona Bowl — January 2, Snoop Dogg and all. A free pep rally January 1 at Jácome Plaza downtown, the Taco Bell New Year's Eve Downtown Bowl Bash on December 31, the Gin & Juice tailgate on game day, and tickets from $30 at thearizonabowl.com, with the money going to local schools and kids' sports organizations. Her Thanksgiving assignment for listeners: talk to your family, pick the date, and fill that stadium.


Next
Next

Guests - Ava Chen, Robert H. Bork, Jr