Betsy Brantner Smith: Grounded Planes, Lost Teens and a Troubled Downtown
Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith (Ret.), spokesperson for the National Police Association, joined Kathleen Winn by phone from Indiana for the Monday edition of Smith & Winn. She and her husband Dave had flown out Friday to see their grandchildren and landed just before the nationwide FAA ground stop began, then planned to fly home Monday afternoon, a stroke of timing Winn called intuition.
The Ground Stop and Aging Technology
Brantner Smith said the disruption showed how out of date much of the federal government's technology is. She told of watching the baggage-claim screens reboot in Phoenix two years ago and seeing a Windows XP logo, an operating system that had not been supported in years, and said the same is true of much of the FBI's computer systems, which she said are in worse shape than those used by many local police agencies. She argued that this administration has handled the problem differently than the last one, taking ownership and asking Congress to pay for upgrades. "The Trump administration is admitting and they've been saying this since they took over the second time that we have a problem," she said. Winn said she agrees with Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy that the money should be provided, and that the equipment involved is older than she is.
Three Salpointe Students
Both women turned to what Brantner Smith called a horrific weekend in Tucson, starting with the deaths of three high school students in a one-car crash on Saturday night. The students were reportedly 16, 17 and 18 years old, and the car caught fire after the crash. The Pima County Sheriff's Department is handling the investigation. Dave Smith used to coach wrestling at Salpointe, she said, which made it personal for her. Having worked many such scenes, she said it sounded to her like high speed, though she cautioned that the facts were not yet known. "These are three families that I hope everyone in Tucson holds close in their hearts," she said.
She used the moment to urge parents to stay involved, pointing to police body-camera video from Fairfax County, Virginia, in which officers respond to a party of underage drinkers and a mother in her 40s denies there is alcohol as drunk teens come down the stairs behind her. "You don't need to be their friends. You need to be their parents," she said. Boundaries, she said, are what children fall back on when they leave home.
The Ronstadt Transit Center
Winn followed with two stabbings at the downtown Ronstadt Transit Center, the first of which left one man dead, apparently as part of a continuing domestic dispute, and the second of which, less than 24 hours later, wounded several people who survived. Brantner Smith said she is troubled that the city plans to expand its transit system while the center remains a hazard after dark. "I don't understand how Regina Romero thinks they're going to keep it safe," she said. She noted that Tucson is roughly the 34th largest city in the country and still has crime that Mesa does not.
Affordability and the New Congress
Brantner Smith said the midterm campaign was about affordability, but that Democrats in Washington are talking about little except investigations and impeachment. She said gas and oil prices were falling as she and Winn spoke. They agreed Democrats are planning two years of obstruction, and said Republicans should remind them each time that their priorities have nothing to do with prices. She and Winn also pointed to roughly 40 million Christians who they said did not vote this year. "We start to lose the things that matter most to us," Winn said.
Winn said she is still examining why Republicans did not win a single seat in LD17, a district with a nine-point Republican advantage, despite turnout around 70 percent.
Girls' Sports and the Senate
Brantner Smith noted that Colorado and Washington have run into resistance to state measures restricting boys' participation in girls' sports, and that the Seattle school board has said it will not comply. She said the issue is a 90-10 issue with voters, noting that Arizona voters approved a ban even as they elected Democrats, and she predicted the fight will move through the courts. She said Senate Majority Leader John Thune could use the weeks before the new Congress arrives to confirm the roughly 138 judges awaiting votes. "Just do your job," she said. She closed with a joke about the boys-and-girls scene in the 1990 film Kindergarten Cop.
Joel Strabala: How Seventeen Extra Ballots Turned Up
Joel Strabala, a member of the Pima County Election Integrity Commission and a newly re-elected chair of LD17, joined Winn to explain what happened last week when the Pima County Recorder's office found a handful of additional early ballots after results had already been declared final. Winn said she wanted to explain it plainly. "This is not sour grapes," she said. "But you can say this is a trend that has never occurred here."
The Timeline
Strabala said the county tabulated the final batch of conditional and provisional ballots on Tuesday, then ran a logic and accuracy test, which compares the machines' tabulation of about 5,700 pre-counted test ballots against the same set after the election, with a Democratic and a Republican observer present. The test passed, which he said shows the software did not change during the election season. On Thursday afternoon, the recorder's office discovered 13 additional early ballots still in their affidavit envelopes, and on Friday it found four more. The Elections Department tabulated each batch, with party observers present, and reposted its "final" results, labeled Upload 12, after each. "We've done final results now three times last week," Winn said.
Did It Change Anything?
Strabala said he checked the closest races, including a tight contest in South Tucson, and found nothing that the 17 ballots could have altered. "It is extremely unlikely that any of the other races were materially affected by the 17 additional votes," he said, based on about five years of observing tabulation. He also said he saw nothing in the data to suggest significant changes anywhere else in Pima County. The frustration, he said, is accountability. Ballots are controlled items in the recorder's office, he said, and they should not go missing and show up later. "It suggests there are problems with respect to accountability of controlled items such as our ballots," he said. Winn said the party is not accusing anyone of anything. She called it a broken process, not a personal matter, and said she did not want to pick on Pima County Recorder Gabriella Cázares-Kelly, only to point out that the job is to keep track of the ballots.
Strabala said the recorder's side of the house, which handles the voter rolls, signature verification and ballot curing, passes the ballots on to the Elections Department, which opens them, checks them against the paperwork and tabulates. He said he had spoken to Elections Director Constance Hargrove on Friday evening, and the canvass, the process for reviewing and closing out the election, is scheduled for November 18th, with the Board of Supervisors expected to consider certification the following Tuesday. He added that anyone who wants to challenge anything can do so only after certification. "It's facts, not feelings," Winn said.
Kathleen Winn on Safety, Elections and What Is Coming
Dismantling Public Safety
Winn spent a segment on what she called a movement to weaken policing. She said the incoming Democratic legislature has discussed eliminating a state public safety commission that coordinates across agencies during a crisis, and that Attorney General Kris Mayes, re-elected, is pursuing a moratorium on AK-47-style rifles. She said she wanted to know what either has to do with affordability.
She pointed to New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's announcement that he is disbanding the NYPD's Strategic Response Group and shifting protest response to a new civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division, housed in the mayor's Office of Community Safety. The group's counterterrorism functions will be folded into an existing command, she said. "Do you really think that citizens are more and better equipped to handle people who are acting out violently?" she asked. Winn said she expects Arizona's new Democratic legislature to bring back bills that failed in recent years, including measures on gun control, education and DEI, and said she wants to ensure the new boys-and-girls sports law is not undone. Jared Weisfeld, author of Special Agent DJ, was expected as a guest to discuss the issue.
The Emergency Alert Test
Winn also relayed that FEMA and the FCC will conduct a nationwide test of the emergency alert system on Tuesday, November 17, at 2:20 p.m. Eastern time, which is 12:20 p.m. in Arizona. Television and radio broadcasts will be interrupted for about a minute with warning tones and a test message. It will not send alerts to cell phones, she said, and there is a backup date of December 3. She said the test follows a failure of old equipment last week and does not signal any emergency. "Don't think the world is coming to an end," she said.
Elections and the Months Ahead
Winn said she plans to leave her post as Pima County Republican Party chair at the next election, scheduled for January 9, after two years in what she called a volunteer position. She told listeners that the party made 42 reports on Election Day, some of them power-related, and that anyone who saw something unusual should file a report now, because legal rights begin once the canvass is certified. She said the state's Democrats will control all statewide offices and, in her figures, hold 20 of 30 Senate seats and 37 of 60 House seats, and that Republicans keep five of the state's nine congressional seats. She congratulated Eli Crane, Abe Hamadeh, Paul Gosar and Mark Lamb. She added that a Republican legislator in Scottsdale's LD3 who won his race has asked for an administrative review and audit of the ballots. She said she supports reviews of voter eligibility, ballot reconciliation, chain of custody and mail-ballot procedures, citing a man who she said had not lived at an address for nine years and received three ballots.
Winn said the party must not do anything illegal and must not set anything on fire. "What we're going to do is continue to push back in the way that we do it," she said. She plugged Perfection Auto Works, thanked listeners, and said the next day's show would focus on a march in Washington for victims and survivors.
Michael Letts: "We Are Far From Done"
Michael Letts, founder, president and CEO of InVest USA, which has provided thousands of bulletproof vests to law enforcement agencies across hundreds of communities, joined Winn for the next segment. Winn said she needed to hear his message. "The battle is still underway," Letts said. "We're not going to let America go down without a fight."
Mamdani's Protest Plan
Letts drew a historical parallel to 1968, when Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert Kennedy were assassinated and the country recovered, and said he expects the same this time. On Mamdani's plan, he asked a simple question. "Would you want to send some social workers into an angry mob?" he said. Law-abiding citizens, he argued, are being marginalized by policies that invite disorder, which in turn creates fear and public support for restrictions on rights. He said that in an angry crowd no amount of reasoning from an unarmed negotiator is going to work. "They're not going to budge with all their friends," he said.
Guns and Criminals
Letts said the answer to gun violence is not disarming law-abiding citizens but changing the penalty for criminals. He proposed that anyone who commits a crime with a gun face an automatic death sentence and no appeal, and said he believes criminals would quickly stop using guns. He said that law-abiding citizens should be able to arm themselves as easily as possible. He and Winn agreed that Democrats in Arizona are unlikely to stop at gun control, and Letts said that they want to weaken law enforcement and the military, the two institutions he said keep the country free. Winn said she expects the state's new legislature to try to undo the state's ICE-related cooperation and that the ICE detention center in Pima County is run under a federal contract with a private landlord that the state may have a hard time reaching.
His Petition
Letts said he has launched a petition on the InVest USA website, InVestUSA.org, calling on the administration to investigate the midterm election results, and that thousands of Americans have responded. He said he is not accusing anyone, only asking that the vote counts be reviewed. "I can deal with the truth," he said. "I can't deal with lies." Winn said that in Arizona nothing can be challenged until the election is certified.
Letts also criticized California Governor Gavin Newsom's recent laws restricting immigration agents and said Democratic governors are positioning themselves for presidential bids. Winn read a report that Los Angeles criminals dressed as gardeners to jam security systems and rob celebrity homes.
On the final stretch of the show, Letts urged unity across party lines. "I'm not worried about making America great again," he said. "I'm worried about saving America." He asked listeners to remember what they owe their children and grandchildren and thanked Winn. "God bless you for what you're doing," he said.