Guests - Joshua Lisec, Mike Emery, Brenda Marts, Jarod Weisfeld

Springfield: The Town That Was Told Not to See It

Joshua Lisec came to Springfield's story the way most of America did — through a viral news cycle that was quickly declared a hoax. His new book, Haitians of Springfield: An Oral History, starts from the opposite question, the one Kathleen Winn read aloud to open the conversation: "What if dismissing a viral news story as a hoax is the real hoax all along?"

Lisec, a New York Times bestselling author and lifelong Ohio resident who lives in Dayton, a short drive from Springfield, spent the book listening to the people who lived the influx. What they describe, he says, is a population replacement carried out between 2021 and 2025 — in Republican, conservative, largely white Christian communities already struggling from NAFTA-era factory losses, the Great Recession, and the opioid crisis.

"So you are being replaced, but you can't say anything about it," Lisec said. "And Republicans fear nothing more than being called racist. They will submit to any humiliation if it means not being called racist."

That fear, he argues, is the mechanism. It ran through every layer of the story he documented — the welfare offices, the city government, and the courts.

The Numbers Nobody Will Say Out Loud

The official narrative, Lisec says, is that Springfield — a city of just under 60,000 people — absorbed between 10,000 and 15,000 Haitian migrants, all of them legal. The whistleblowers he interviewed inside Ohio's own system tell a different story.

"The whistleblowers I've spoken to for the book from the state of Ohio estimate that it was not 10,000. It was between 32,200 and 35,000 Haitians. So we're at least triple the official narrative."

"And every aspect of the story you realize is a lie," he added. "Not just a little bit of a lie. It's completely a lie."

The population growth has been marketed to developers as a resurgence — build homes, rezone, expand — while the true count stays unspoken because no census has forced it into the open. Lisec has a phrase for the enthusiasm behind it: "Number go up, number go up. It's always number go up with country club Republicans, with the gentry, regardless of the harms that that has upon the local population."

Most of the migrants, he says, entered the country illegally and were shielded from deportation by Temporary Protected Status. When President Trump canceled TPS, three federal judges in a row temporarily suspended the order — all of them appointed by Democratic presidents, Obama or Biden, and, Lisec notes, all of them raised race in their decisions.

"We on the right, we like to say, oh, I don't see race," Lisec said. "Yeah, but race sees you. I don't see color, yet color sees you."

In July, the Supreme Court ruled that the Department of Homeland Security could rescind TPS — the power belongs to the executive branch, and the judiciary could not intervene. With TPS expired, the vast majority of Springfield's Haitian population is now in the country illegally. But instead of mass self-deportation or a large ICE operation, Lisec says, churches and nonprofits are helping the migrants hide from ICE, delivering food, holding fundraisers — Hollywood celebrities among the donors — and driving them to and from work, with money funneled to the organizations doing it.

The Sublet Scam

The book began, Lisec says, on a hike earlier this year, when a friend mentioned her brother, a Springfield landlord, and his troubles with Haitian tenants. The scheme he uncovered works like this: a tenant rents a house, moves out, and secretly sublets it to as many as 15 other migrants, charging each of them $200 to $300 — keeping the property and the profit, while the actual landlord gets nothing and loses track of his own tenant.

In one case, the landlord finally evicted the 15 men subletting his house and found they had been raising and breeding mice inside it — hundreds of mice, kept in pens and coops that were, the landlord told Lisec, the only part of the house that was well taken care of. The rest of the property, he said, looked like "the zombie apocalypse." Whether the mice were being raised for food or for ritual, the landlord did not know.

Kathleen, who spent years in real estate, noted the obvious: subleasing without the owner's permission violates any good lease. Lisec's point is that none of it gets stopped, because no one in authority wants to be the one called racist.

Haitians of Springfield is available from Amazon and Barnes & Noble and in select stores nationwide. Lisec's primary business is Lisec Ghostwriting — he ghostwrites nonfiction for business owners, executives, and other VIPs. Kathleen promised to have him back: the fight over immigration enforcement is, as she put it, the battleground of the next two years, and Tucson is fighting its own version of it, including a battle to keep a detention center open.

Your Mailbox Is Lying to You About Your Car

Mike Emery of Perfection Auto Works — a Winn Tucson sponsor, in business in Tucson since the 1990s, now joining the show monthly — started with the stack of paper every car owner knows: the notices. Some announce that your warranty period is about to expire. Some look exactly like recalls. Most are neither.

"When you get those notices, and you think, oh, this is a recall, it's typically not," he said. "It's generally a solicitation for a warranty program. And they don't like to cover a whole lot of stuff."

Factory warranties are real — most cars carry at least three years or 50,000 miles, some up to 100,000. The aftermarket warranty letters are a sales pitch, and, as Kathleen put it, they work like health insurance: "It seems like it's going to take care of everything. And then when you try to use it, it doesn't take care of anything."

His core advice is simpler: if your car makes a noise, feels different, or lights up a warning, deal with it now. "That's probably the most brilliant thing I've ever heard you say," Emery told her, "because if you immediately deal with whatever noise or check engine light or whatever the incident may be at the time, time is essence. And if you wait, it's going to cost you more money."

The tire pressure light is the one everybody ignores — and a tire driven low destroys itself, at $200 to $300 for a decent replacement. The check engine light is the other. Any independent shop can read the codes; Perfection Auto Works does it free of charge. And when a repair estimate comes back, Emery applies a rule before recommending anything: "My typical rule of thumb is about 50 percent of the value. We do not want you to spend more than 50 percent of the value of the car."

The BMW Recall That Can Burn Your House Down

One recall, though, is very real. Emery flagged a BMW recall covering approximately 730,000 cars from about 2012 to 2018 — X3, 3 Series, 5 Series, and the other cars of those generations. A connector to the water pump takes on water over time, shorts, and starts fires.

"BMW is recommending if you have any of those vehicles, do not park your car in the garage," he said — because a car fire in a garage is a house fire. Perfection Auto Works keeps the database: call 520-323-8650 with your vehicle information and they will tell you within seconds whether your car qualifies, free of charge. Every car that comes into the shop gets its VIN run as a matter of routine.

The shop sits at 1046 North Beverly, on the corner of Beverly and Speedway, and has answered the same phone number for 35 years. Kathleen's review of her own Jeep's return: "When I got it back, it was like getting back a brand new car."

A Tucson Voice Gone Silent

The segment closed on a somber note. Emery's longtime friend Dan Hicks — they went from Lizzie Brown Elementary and Townsend Junior High to Sabino High School together — died last week in Connecticut at 64, of an acute illness, according to his wife, Hannah Storm.

Hicks, a University of Arizona journalism graduate, spent 35 years at NBC Sports: the voice of Notre Dame football, Olympic broadcasts, PGA golf. As a kid, Emery recalled, Hicks would go to Tucson Toros games with a tape recorder and practice announcing along with the game — a hometown kid rehearsing his way to the network. An accomplished school athlete himself, he turned to broadcasting after injury ended his playing days.

"He was great at what he did," Emery said. "He was able to ad lib. He knew the greats." A product of Tucson who went national, and, as Kathleen put it, gone too soon.

This Day in History: The Suez Canal

Kathleen marked the date with a piece of history. On November 17, 1869, the Suez Canal opened — 120 miles connecting the Mediterranean and the Red Seas, dug largely by laborers with picks and shovels after construction began in 1859. As opened, it was only 25 feet deep and 200 to 300 feet wide; fewer than 500 ships navigated it in its first full year. Today dozens of ships a day carry more than 300 million tons of goods a year through it.

Her point was the connection: nearly everything we buy moves through chokepoints like that one, and the local and the global are the same story told at different scales — which is why the show keeps coming back to who governs, and how.

Ninety People Trying to Spend My Money

Brenda Marts goes to the meetings most people skip — Tucson mayor and council, the county, and, on November 12, a housing town hall put on by Arizona Town Hall and the Arizona Housing Coalition. About 100 people registered; roughly 90 were in the room, all of them there to talk about housing. Marts, a business owner, housing provider, and landlord, sat in the room and did the math from the other side of the table.

"I sat in that room and there were 90 people trying to spend my money," she said. "And nobody thinks like I think, because I'm on the other side of all of this."

The missing perspective in government and nonprofit housing discussions, she argues, is the perspective of the people who actually provide housing. "It's really easy to spend somebody else's money. And for housing, it can't make it cheaper. When you spend someone else's money, it makes housing more expensive — no matter if you're buying, if you're renting, whatever it is you're trying to do."

The proof, she says, is in how the money gets spent. A young man installing acoustical ceilings told her an "affordable housing" project he was working on had specified the most expensive tile available. And then there is Tucson House, the city's flagship: "Two hundred million dollars — it's more than that. That's the number they put out there. So it's probably closer to $300 million for 300 units. I mean, $550,000 to remodel a one bedroom. And y'all are okay with that?"

Run like a business, she says, the return would take 30, 40, 50 years — it will never come back. And the budgets are built so the money can't be followed: line items change names from year to year, so last year's section can't be compared to this year's.

The County Pays the Other Side's Lawyer

Of everything Marts described, the eviction system drew the sharpest exchange. When a tenant stops paying, the landlord pays an attorney and goes to court. Pima County, she says, now pays an attorney for the other side — and a missed dotting of an i buys the tenant another week. The county's eviction legal services operation, she added, spends so much on administration — tablecloths, stickers, advertising — that when you call, nobody answers the phone.

"We didn't go to court because I wanted to," she said. "We went to court because I'm starving now and I need to recoup my losses and start over."

Every layer of that expense lands in the same place: "Who's going to pay that expense? Oh, it's going to the next tenant." Filing fees are higher for evictions than for other court processes. The city's roll-off dumpster fee — a cost of every eviction cleanout — is $182 now and $250 next year. Water, power, fees: "They're nickel and diming us to death."

Meanwhile the government's own "affordable" product competes against the private market it taxes: HUD's rate for a one-bedroom is $1,000 a month, while Marts rents one-bedrooms for $800. "Why am I not renting at the HUD rate? Because I don't actually need to do that — until you keep taxing me." Pima County wants to spend $200 million on affordable housing; a new bond is already being worked on after Proposition 425 passed; and with roughly five years of planned increases, she warns, longtime homeowners who have paid off their mortgages will owe more in property taxes than their Social Security pays. She is downsizing her own rentals — and notes that rentals are exactly how generational wealth gets built, the very goal the county claims to pursue.

Her ask of the town hall was procedural, and she put it in writing: "I strongly encourage you to invite private property owners, property managers and people who have actually experienced eviction. A discussion that includes only government agencies, nonprofits and advocates does not provide a complete picture." Marts, who recently became second vice chair of LD17, says she has decided to start showing up to rooms she would rather skip — she grew up believing you take care of yourself and make your own money, and she intends to keep saying so in person. Her late friend Chris Sheaf left her a book before he died with a warning she now repeats: what the city of Tucson wants to do is the exact wrong thing to do.

Send in the Counselors

Jarred Weisfeld arrived with a question Kathleen borrowed from her other show: "Smith and Winn — more deadly than a Smith and Wesson." New York's mayor has decided that when protesters take to the streets, the city will send counselors instead of law enforcement, disbanding the NYPD's elite tactical unit — the Strategic Response Group — in favor of a Community Dialogue and Deescalation Division. What could possibly go wrong?

"First of all, they're not allowed to have any weapons," Weisfeld said of the counselors. "Number two, they only responded to six percent of protests — that were the violent protests. So you're sending these civilians to violent protests. Nothing good is going to happen."

The unit being disbanded, he noted, is precisely the one trained for this — officers who specialize in crowd control and de-escalation in major cities. "Would you send a PTO mom into the middle of a riot in downtown New York, Chicago, L.A. or anywhere else to protect?" And in Mamdani's defense, Weisfeld conceded the point Kathleen raised: "He ran on this. He said he was going to do it. He's doing it. So you can't cry after the fact." The surprise, to Weisfeld, is Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch going along with it without resigning. His prediction: "That unit will be back together in like three and a half weeks. They'll call it something else. But they'll be back."

Special Agent DJ

The answer, Weisfeld says, is more people like DJ Daniel. Devarjaye "DJ" Daniel was the young boy honored as an honorary Secret Service agent during the President's address to Congress. Diagnosed with terminal brain cancer, he is 14 now; the radiation and chemotherapy affected the parts of his brain for reading and writing, and he keeps going anyway. He has been sworn in more than 4,400 times — by agencies across the country and around the world, including, Weisfeld jokes, the Israeli police.

DJ's mission began during Hurricane Harvey, when he and his two brothers were displaced and police officers offered the boys pizza — the only people, Weisfeld says, who helped the family. "That's the day when he said, I want to be a police officer. They helped me out. I want to help others."

Weisfeld, an entertainment producer and literary representative, had his own mission: an armed school resource officer or trained security in every school in America, and a search for the advocate who could carry that message. "There's nobody better than the kid from the State of the Union." He tracked down DJ's father and pitched an inspirational book — written largely through text messages over the father's phone, with DJ commenting on the artwork, and finished in four months because DJ is terminal and Weisfeld wanted the finished book in his hands. Their designer, Holly, turned it around. Special Agent DJ came out at the end of September; Fox News featured it; Kathleen bought six copies for Christmas gifts.

The book's message to children is simple: "If you get lost in the mall, go to a police officer to help you find your parents. In school, if something's happening, go to a police officer. They will help you. Police aren't the bad guys. They're the good guys." Don't let, Weisfeld says, "the two percent of the parents in these schools dictate the safety of children," and don't punish the 99.99 percent of great officers for the acts of a few.

He pointed to Florida's model under Governor Ron DeSantis: where a school lacks an SRO or a trained, armed adult, superintendents don't get paid until there is one. Weisfeld wants the federal government to make it funding-based nationwide. In his own district — six schools, four with SROs and two without, at about $40,000 per school — "You can't find eighty thousand dollars out of sixty-two million dollars? That's like bonkers."

DJ, meanwhile, is not slowing down — he's at CPAC and the major conventions, still getting deputized every weekend. Asked when he'll be done, his answer says it best: "When my car runs out of gas."


Next
Next

Guests - Betsy Smith, Joel Strabala, Michael Letts