Guests - Betsy Smith, Dan McCauley, Kelly Walker

Bring Back the SRG

Betsy Brantner Smith called in from the road — rental car loaded with three dogs and Thanksgiving cargo, somewhere around Las Cruces — with a warning she'd already delivered on Fox News that morning. New York's incoming mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has announced he will disband the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, the elite unit that oversees every large-scale event in the city: demonstrations, the Super Bowl, parades. The SRG is part crowd control, part intelligence, part counterterrorism — and its first big test would have been the 100th Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade.

"Why don't you just put a big target on New York City and the Macy's Day Parade?" Betsy asked. "That's exactly what he's doing." The money saved goes to more civilian employees — unarmed civilians keeping the parade safe. And Mamdani wasn't done: today he announced he will empty Rikers Island, telling the district attorneys of all five boroughs to get ready to receive its 6,600 prisoners back into borough facilities. "What could go wrong?" Betsy asked. "Do you want the short list or the long list?"

This, she argues, is a playbook, not a policy: Gavin Newsom commuting the death sentences of California murderers, prisons emptied under the banner of decarceration, specialized police units dissolved — a soft reintroduction of defund the police. And it lands on voters who thought they'd bought something else entirely. "We bought the fake affordability story," Kathleen said. "So now we're going to say, okay, go crazy. You told us you were going to make it affordable — you're just going to make it completely unlivable." Betsy agreed: "They just want to make it dangerous." Nor has the promised affordability arrived — rent in New York City, she noted, is still sky high. "When you weaken the police force, you weaken the nation. They don't give a crap about affordability. They are going to reallocate police resources away from armed law enforcement, make it easier to commit crimes, make it more dangerous for everybody — and when it's dangerous, people turn to the government to protect them. That's how they control us." She even has a theory for the personal edge: Mamdani was arrested as a young legislator, by SRG officers. There's also a campaign promise being kept — he said he'd disband the unit, and the dismantling is slated for sometime next year; the announcement now, before the parade, was for the splash.

The two also took up Congresswoman Adelita Grijalva's advocacy for a pregnant woman in immigration custody facing deportation. Betsy's answer was blunt: women have babies in custody all the time, and the fastest help available is to stop fighting the deportation — "expedite it, get her home, so she can have her baby at home." Kathleen's bewilderment was the whiplash: the same movement that calls an unborn child a clump of cells discovers a baby worth saving when the politics line up. "Pick a side. I don't care — but stay there more than ten minutes." Betsy added the voter-roll coda, only half joking: dead dogs have turned up on voter rolls — fortunately, she says, not in Arizona. "Maybe my live dogs are on the voter rolls," Kathleen laughed. "I should search for Remington Smith and see how he voted."

The National Police Association, where Betsy serves as spokesperson, has partnered with Change.org on a petition — change.org, "bring back SRG" — and she's asking Arizonans to sign it, because where the NYPD goes, American law enforcement follows. Tucson's police department has its own crowd-control and intelligence units. "You don't think Regina Romero wants to get rid of both of those? And Kate Gallego in Phoenix is watching to see how this shakes out." Kathleen recalled the opposite model: the 2015 Super Bowl in Arizona, when city, county, state, and federal agencies worked as one under Glendale Chief Debora Black — the safest Super Bowl there was, so good the Phoenix team went to San Francisco the next year to coach theirs. Officers, meanwhile, are voting with their feet: the NYPD is fleeing for Florida. The petition's pitch is simple — public safety is not a political football, and it takes about 25 seconds to sign.

The Trust Trap

Then a retired attorney with a warning that could save a listener's house. Dan McCauley practiced in Philadelphia, with work in New York, New Jersey, and Delaware, before escaping to Arizona. His subject: the revocable living trust — and the insurance claim that never gets paid.

Most people with assets put their house into a trust: it avoids probate and controls how assets pass down. The deed moves from you, personally, to the trustee of your trust. What almost nobody does is update the insurance. "Under the law, you no longer own that house. Your trust owns it. And some of these insurance companies are saying: your trust owns it now, you're not on the policy as the owner — we're not going to pay the claim." It is happening in California, where fire victims are rebuilding — or not: Kathleen noted Malibu property values down 27 percent, with only about 20 percent rebuilt. McCauley's former client, a corporate executive with an extremely expensive California property, sent his agent the warning. "The agent said, it's nonsense, don't worry about it. He said, 'I got this from my old lawyer — check on it.' About a week later he got a call: we've put you on individually as well as your trust, because they may have denied your claim."

The fix costs nothing but a phone call: make sure the policy names you and your trust as insureds. McCauley learned the hard way how insurers think — his own water-leak claim, a broken pipe, was blamed on termites, and he ended up paying for the floors himself. "The insurance companies aren't your friend. If they can deny a claim, they will." The same sloppiness infects the trusts themselves: people create them and never fund them properly, never retitle the accounts. For a married couple, the trust barely operates while both spouses live — it becomes critical only after the second death, which can be twenty years after it was drafted, with nobody having looked at the funding since. Investment and savings accounts (not retirement accounts) belong in the trust's name so the children can step in with the document in hand; otherwise the kids call the bank after a death and hit a legal department that won't surrender the money without a court order. "It's rare, but it does happen — and you just don't have to go to court." His prescription: have the trust reviewed every four or five years, and always after a move to a new state — a surviving spouse who relocates to be near grandchildren in North Carolina needs a North Carolina lawyer to check the trust against North Carolina law. And do it before the crisis: "I can't see a fight with an insurance company, even a simple one, costing less than $7,000 or $10,000. Why not just make the change on the policy and not worry about getting rejected?" The ultimate loser if you don't, Kathleen added, won't be you. It'll be your children and grandchildren.

A Hundred Thousand Dollars to Contest a School Board Race

McCauley has fought an election contest himself — because the candidate couldn't find another lawyer willing to take it; they were all afraid of trouble with the bar. He got the trouble with the bar. His verdict: the system was designed to be fast and cheap, and it has been perverted into the opposite.

Arizona's election-contest law was built for speed: file within five days of certification, the winner answers in five days, a judge hears it within days — so the true winner can be sworn in on time. The legislature revisited the law five or six times and never once said the ordinary rules of court should apply, because rules of court mean depositions, discovery, expert witnesses — activity, and cost. But the rules crept in anyway, and now a serious contest runs like any other lawsuit. "When I tell you you can spend a hundred thousand dollars with a lawyer for a school board seat, I'm not kidding you." Parties protect their statewide candidates financially; a thinly funded local candidate funds the fight from friends and family and ends up six figures in debt to a lawyer — so most never fight at all. His ask: legislators should state definitively that the rules of court don't apply — the judge hears both sides and rules, quickly, the way it was intended. Kathleen's bottom line matches the week's theme: the voter rolls remain Arizona's biggest problem, and a system priced out of ordinary people's reach can't correct itself.

The Club

The conversation widened to Washington's revolving door. Members of Congress trade stocks on knowledge the rest of us go to jail for — Martha Stewart went to prison; a congresswoman can arrive with the value of her home and leave, it's rumored, with $20 million on a salary just under $200,000. "Nancy Pelosi is a perfect example." Even the president, McCauley said carefully, benefits from meeting the owners. "If you're going to go in and serve the people, you're not serving yourself. There shouldn't be a double standard."

That lens turned to the changing of the guard at the White House: Susie Wiles out as chief of staff, Stephen Miller in — and, as reported in the news and discussed on the show, allegations that Wiles used her old firm, Ballard, to get people in front of the president while money flowed, with her daughter now working the same trade at another firm. McCauley was careful: "I don't think it's legal — and I want to be careful, because I have no firsthand knowledge. I only know what's been reported." His objection is structural: lobbyists inside the government are expected to ignore the people they made serious money with, forever. "To try to put that at 100 percent successful is like betting $150 on 22 black at a roulette table." At minimum, he says, the public has a right to know people's pasts — and to complain to their representatives when the past disqualifies.

Five Minutes, a Hundred Pages

Then the future walked in. McCauley's paralegal — with him since 2007, "as smart in the law as any lawyer I know" — is working a family case where children are fighting over a trust. He fed everything into an AI system he pays a modest fee to use: the complaint, the answer, the pleadings, the hearing, the ruling — hundreds of pages. "In less than five minutes, he got a hundred-page analysis of everything: what the law says, what laws applied, what laws he didn't apply that he should have, how the judge ruled, whether the judge was correct or incorrect." McCauley read for two and a half hours. "I have been a lawyer a long time, and I'm telling you, it was stunning." Thirty years ago, his old Philadelphia firm would have charged $20,000 or $30,000 for that analysis — in yesterday's dollars. A partner at a large New York firm reached the obvious conclusion: hire fewer young lawyers, because the research now takes five minutes instead of weeks.

Kathleen added the caution that keeps it honest: garbage in, garbage out. The paralegal put everything in — the whole laundry basket — which is why the analysis was comprehensive. And McCauley was explicit: "I am not suggesting people fight these cases themselves by feeding information into an AI. You can get hammered doing that." But for experienced hands, he sees costs coming down — and maybe, Kathleen joked, that's the affordability promise somebody finally keeps: lawyers becoming affordable.

Weaponization Wednesday

Kelly Walker — publisher of Freedom Talk magazine, and himself a targeted school parent who faced government weaponization — came back to announce a show of his own: Weaponization Wednesday, premiering Wednesday, December 2, on the Freedom Talk YouTube channel and at realfreedomtalk.com. Each week he'll bring on two or three victims to tell their stories briefly, then talk through them — with a form on the advocacy page where anyone targeted can submit their own. He's reaching out to Michael Flynn. He's also working with attorney Peter Ticktin — Tina Peters's lawyer — who is handling a tort claim for a group of parents on contingency: "Otherwise there's no way I could afford it."

His message to fellow victims fretting about the new Congress: if you're in the judicial system now, a change of gavels doesn't end your case. The harder truth is bipartisan. Todd Blanche put out a report on weaponization — "the report's fine, but it doesn't do anything to help people in their situation. It doesn't bring those responsible to bear." Under Republican leadership, Walker says flatly, nothing was done for the victims of weaponization — "and it's one of the reasons we took a beating in the election. Nobody got any help." The targeted-parents list itself crosses party lines: Republican, Democrat, Independent. "What one party does, the other party can do in return."

Kathleen connected it to a fight in Hermosa Beach, California, where citizens are battling officials over a lifeguard station permanently painted in rainbow colors — a blue city of 20,000, roughly 40 percent conservative, where officials assumed residents were too timid and worn down to complain. They were wrong. For Walker, it's the same machinery: parents who spoke at meetings — heated, sometimes, but never violent — were arrested and jailed on a presumption of guilt, criminalized for an opinion. "Nobody should be persecuted for having an opinion." His distinction worth keeping: restitution is not reparations. Restitution is specific damages to specific people — driven out of jobs, buried in legal fees, in our own day. And his warning is Thermopylae: the people who stood up early, at great cost, were standing between everyone else and what comes next. "If you wipe out the 300 Spartans, everybody else is vulnerable. You could be next — and you probably will be next, because the people who got hit hard were just a few years ahead of what's planned for everyone else."

One more thread before the close: Kathleen has been hearing, in just the last few weeks, that California children are being funneled into Arizona's foster care system — allegedly children of incarcerated parents, now Arizona's responsibility. Who are these children, where exactly are they coming from, and who's funding it? She put the questions to Walker honestly: "You may not know the answers. It's just something I've been made aware of." It stands as an open question for a future show.

Kathleen closed the week with Tucson's own bright spot: the 32nd annual Downtown Parade of Lights & Festival, Saturday, December 5 — festival from 3 p.m. at Jácome Plaza, parade at 6:30 as the sun goes down, Santa and the Grinch on hand, Bustos Media a proud sponsor, appliance man Chris Edwards as parade marshal. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving week ahead.


Next
Next

Guests - Jonathan Dever, Dave Smith